Two women are walking with their dog in a field. Just as they start to get a little frisky, their dog starts barking loudly in the distance. They follow the sound and discover a horrific sight: June's half-eaten dead body, now filled with maggots. Can no one ever get a little action on this show without discovering something terrible?
Dylan and Sarah arrive at Cam's to help the search party right when Vaughn arrives and reveals the discovery of June's body. At the morgue, the pathologist reveals that June was administered a paralytic and died of respiratory failure.
Dylan and Alison appear on Lisa Ann Follows' show to discuss the murders. Alison is nervous and lacks confidence, but Dylan comes across as charismatic and charming. He's a natural, though Sarah isn't super thrilled about that.
Alan visits Tom at the prison and hands him over an envelope. Alan says it changes nothing between them, and Tom opens it. He's not particularly pleased with what he finds inside, and he asks to be taken back to his cell.
Sarah and Robin question whether Alan might have any motive for the murders. They sneak into the church to snoop for clues. In a back office, Sarah discovers a bag containing a hammer and nails. Is this the Executioner's murder kit?
Alison resents Dylan for doing so well in the interview while she bombed, so she resorts to hacking into June's text messages to get some good dirt. Dylan disapproves of this illegality, but relents for the sake of a good story. Who needs ethics?
Sarah tells Cam about her concerns regarding his father, but he won't hear it. He in turn accuses Dylan, since the murders only started when he arrived, and Sarah comes back with a suggestion that Cam killed June to get revenge for her cheating. Can't we all just get along?
Alan shows up at the gallery and tells Sarah a moderately threatening story about a plucked chicken before revealing that he knows what she told Cam, and that she should be careful. Watch your back, Sarah!
The Bulletin publishes June's text messages with Trent, and Lisa is pleased, saying they will be the top story on her show that night. Sarah arrives at the office and confronts Dylan, asking how he could do something so cruel to Cam. She storms out in anger.
On the show, Alison makes a plea to the Executioner asking for an interview, stunning Lisa and Dylan with her gall. She returns to her car, where she discovers a note from the Executioner with a time and place to meet.
The Executioner meets Alison at the Foundry where she records the interview. The Executioner reveals the paralytic found in June's body to prove who he/she is, and says he/she only kills those who truly deserve to die.
The Executioner tells Alison that the Bulletin is just as much of a judge and jury as he/she is, and asks if she has any sins weighing heavily on her conscience. She replies that she does not, and the Executioner stares at her before leaving. Now, this is a story!
Alison shows the footage to Lisa and Dylan, and Lisa says she's going to build an entire special around the interview. Dylan asks if they should send the footage to the police, but Lisa declines. She's going to fly Alison out to New York for the taping.
Sarah meets with Ronald in an attempt to get her parents' sex tapes out of police custody. She threatens to reveal about his affair with her grandmother, and that gets him to act real quick.
At the bar, Lisa asks Alison how dirty she's willing to get to get a story. Alison reveals that she fabricated emails implicating Bennie Peterson in the disappearance of his daughter, Ariel. Bennie eventually committed suicide. Damn, Alison, that's cold. Little do they know that Dylan overhears every word.
Sarah and Robin see Alan getting into his car with the murder kit, so they follow him. They arrive at a mysterious building through a back entrance and they hear screams coming from inside. They burst through a door and find Alan being nailed to a cross by a woman in leather. Well, this got weird...
Alison is picked up by a car for her flight to New York, but she fails to notice that the driver is a familiar hooded figure… and she wakes up in the Foundry with the Executioner standing over her. She begs for her life, but the Executioner is merciless, slitting her throat.
A police officer arrives at Sarah's with the copies of the sex tapes, which she proceeds to watch. After several hours of eyeball-scorching sex, she discovers one of the men in the videos looks like a young Tom Winston… hmmm…
At a local fast food place, a young man bites into his chicken nugget to discover it's not chicken… it's an ear! The police arrive and discover Alison's head in the deep fryer. If that's not enough to put you off fast food, we don't know what will.
Dylan arrives and questions Vaughn about who they found. He says Alison never made it to her flight and the biblical punishment for greed is burning in hot oil. Sick of his questions, Vaughn shrugs him off and drives home…
…Where he proceeds to go down into his basement and open a locked door. Inside a young woman sings to her son… Ariel Peterson! Vaughn, you are more messed up than we could have imagined…